Gerson Digital : Sweden

RKD STUDIES

3.1 Legacy of Dutch 17th-Century Painting in Sweden


1
Olof Arenius
Portrait of Charles van Baerle (1715-1771), dated 1736
Amersfoort, Rijksdienst voor het Cultureel Erfgoed, inv./cat.nr. C 958

2
Olof Arenius
Portrait of a woman, probably Anna Constantia van Baerle (1714-1778) (?), dated 1735
Amersfoort, Rijksdienst voor het Cultureel Erfgoed, inv./cat.nr. C 959


In essence the 18th century in Sweden provides the same picture as do the other Scandinavian countries: the French approach replaces the Dutch one. This is most clearly seen in portrait painting. Even artists such as Olof Arenius (1700-1766) who, following on an apprenticeship with David von Krafft (1655-1724), spent six years in the Dutch Republic [1-2], and Johan Pasch I (1706-1769), who lived there from 1732 to 1734, hardly incorporated anything Dutch in their work. The Rococo decorations of Pasch are comparable to the playful pictures by Jacob de Wit (1695-1754), but this still does not make them Dutch in spirit.

Occasional copies after Netherlandish, mostly Flemish models do not count. Thus Lorenz Pasch II (1733-1805) is to have rendered an altarpiece after Cornelis de Vos (1584-1651) in Ekenäs (Finland) [3],1 whereas the miniaturist Peter Adolf Hall (1739-1793) and others worked after models by Van Dyck and Mierevelt [4-5]. Carl Gustav Pilo (1711-1792) was an outsider insofar as his models were Rembrandt and the Venetians while French taste otherwise ruled.2 But even with him, one can hardly speak of Dutch influence [6-7].

3
Lorenz Pasch (II)
The Lamentation of Christ, before 1797
Ekenäs (Finland), Tammisaaren Kirkko


4
Peter Adolf Hall after Michiel van Mierevelt
Miniature portrait of Axel Oxenstierna (1583-1654), dated 1786
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NMB 74

5
Peter Adolf Hall after Anthony van Dyck
Portrait of Anton Triest, Bishop of Ghent (1577-1657), dated 1775
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NMS 611


6
Carl Gustav Pilo
Self portrait of Carl Gustav Pilo (1711-1792), c. 1780
Stockholm, Konstakademien

7
Carl Gustav Pilo
The Cobbler's Family, dated 1772
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 1228


8
Alexander Lauréus
Woman with a Lantern, dated 1818
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 1218

9
Alexander Lauréus
Woman with a burning Candle, dated 1818
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 1217


The paintings of the fijnschilders Dou and Van Mieris are better reconcilable with the French taste of the time. In the 18th century we also encounter such traditional Dutch compositions as ‘Girl at a Window-sill’ or genre scenes by candle- or torchlight, done in Rococo colors, in France itself. The Swedish example for such a mixing of styles is Alexander Lauréus (1783-1823) (e.g., genre picture of 1818 in Stockholm) [8-9].3

Still-life painting continued to depend on Dutch models, both the trompe-l’oeil and the decorative flower piece. In Sweden, Carl Hofverberg (1695-1765) is a good example of the former approach (Hunting Equipment and Newspapers on a Wall, dated 1737, collection Countess E. Bielke, Stockholm) [10],4 whereas Lorens Lönberg (1726-1811) can paint a flowerpot which would do credit to Jan van Huijsum (1682-1749) or Herman van der Mijn (1684-1741) (Auction London 29.3.1928, no. 85, signed and dated 1771) [11]. Pehr Hilleström (1732-1816), who stopped off in the Dutch Republic on his way back from Paris, also betrays a Dutch conception in his still lifes and plain genre pieces [12-13]. An immaculate rendering down to the smallest detail is generally a Dutch trait.

The Dutch element in landscape painting was the same in Sweden as in Germany and France at this time, being inspired by the Both-Berchem group.5 Naturally these are not the only examples. Other foreigners probably have a much greater share in the overall picture. But when artists reached back to Dutch landscape forms at all, it was to those of the Arcadian landscape and not to the pictures of Jacob van Ruisdael and Allaert van Everdingen. The landscapes of Elias Martin (1739-1818) took over much of this Arcadian style [14-15]. Johan Philip Korn (1727-1796) continued the Saftleven-Griffier vedute (Uppsala University) [16-17].6

In later Classicistic landscape painting, reminiscences of Philip Wouwerman may occasionally shine through. Even in the 19th century there are Romantic landscapes (e.g. by Carl Johan Fahlcrantz, 1774-1861 and Alfred Thörne, 1850-1916) that resurrect Aelbert Cuyp’s sunlight or imitate Jan Both’s golden tone [18-20] – as in the Netherlands itself.7

10
Carl Hofverberg
Trompe l'oeil of a letter rack with duelling pistols, dated 1737
Stockholm, Livrustkammaren, inv./cat.nr. 16672 (68: 2)

11
Lorens Lönberg
Flowers in a carved vase, dated 1771
sale Vienna (Dorotheum) 1985-09-10/18, lot 468


12
Pehr Hilleström
Still life
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 2268

13
Pehr Hilleström
Young woman plucking poultry
Malmö/Stockholm, collection K.E. Steneberg (1927)


14
Elias Martin
Landscape with a waterfall and cattle
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 1351

15
Elias Martin
Landscape with cattle, dated 1785
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NMB 411


16
Johan Philip Korn
River landscape, 1775
Uppsala, Uppsala universitets konstsamlingar, inv./cat.nr. UU 171

17
Johan Philip Korn
River landscape, dated 1775
Uppsala, Uppsala universitets konstsamlingar, inv./cat.nr. UU 172


18
Carl Johan Fahlcrantz
Vast landscape with Västerås in the background
sale Stockholm (Bukoswki) 2009-11-25, lot 263

19
Carl Johan Fahlcrantz
Kalmar Castle by moonlight, dated 1835
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NM 955

20
Carl Johan Fahlcrantz
View of Kristiania (Oslo)
Stockholm, Nationalmuseum, inv./cat.nr. NMDrh 25


Notes

1 [Van Leeuwen/Roding 2024] It concerns a copy after the central canvas (transferred from panel) of a triptych, formerly attributed to Cornelis de Vos, in the Onze-Lieve-Vrouwekathedraal in Antwerp (RKDimages 311803). Pasch could have seen the model in Antwerp when the work was still in the Sint-Andrieskerk in 1765-1766. It is also possible that Pasch made his full-length copy after the 17th-century copy in the Nationalmuseum (RKDimages 312171). It cannot be ruled out that the version in Stockholm was the original central part of the triptych in Antwerp, which was sold separately by the church in 1809; the Stockholm version is first recorded in 1816.

2 [Gerson 1942/1983] Strömbom 1924.

3 [Van Leeuwen/Roding 2024] Lauréus studied Dutch paintings in Sweden, the Netherlands and Paris. For copies after Gerard Dou, see RKDimages 312375 and RKDimages 312379. On his way to Paris he stayed in Amsterdam and The Hague, where he copied Rembrandt (RKDimages 312199).

4 [Gerson 1942/1983] I owe the photograph of the picture by C. Hofverberg to Dr. K.E. Steneberg, who will publish the work of this unknown artist.

5 [Van Leeuwen/Roding 2024] Gerson refers to the combined emulation of the styles of Jan Both (1615/22-1652) and Nicolaes Berchem (1621/2-1683). For this style in Germany, see Gerson/Van Leeuwen 2018, p. 4.3. See also: Van Leeuwen 2021, p. 204.

6 [Van Leeuwen/Roding 2024] Erroneously, Gerson also lists Johann Jacob Koller (1746-1798), who is a Swiss artist.

7 [Van Leeuwen/Roding 2024] Fahlcrantz had a painting collection of Netherlandish artists and later painters who worked in Dutch style, which was auctioned after the death of his widow on 20 April 1891, see Upmark/Göthe 1891. However, we do not see Dutch connotations in the work of Alfred Thörne.